| Peter | 67% |
| Neither -- they would keep fighting for infinity | 20% |
| Hiro | 13% |
| The Amazing Race | 63% |
| Survivor | 16% |
| The Apprentice | 9% |
| Dancing With the Stars | 7% |
| Project Runway | 5% |
| Ability to heal | 36% |
| Telekinesis | 29% |
| Invisibility | 16% |
| Time travel | 15% |
| Mindreading | 4% |