| Who had the most intriguing hookup? | |
| JENNIFER ANISTON & JOHN MAYER | |
  | 43% |
| NATALIE PORTMAN & DEVENDRA BANHART | |
| 4% |
| KATE HUDSON & LANCE ARMSTRONG | |
| 13% |
| LAUREN CONRAD & KYLE HOWARD | |
| 5% |
| BRITNEY SPEARS & ADNAN GHALIB | |
| 13% |
| DREW BARRYMORE & JUSTIN LONG | |
| 8% |
| DREW BARRYMORE & ED WESTWICK | |
| 6% |
| KIRSTEN DUNST & JUSTIN LONG | |
| 1% |
| MANDY MOORE & RYAN ADAMS | |
| 7% |